| Platinum | Sour Jo's |
| Gold | Valley Buns Bakery and Deli |
| Silver | Raglan Street Foods |
| Bronze | McGuire's Donuts |
| Bronze | Ullrich's |
| Top Pick | Burnt Bridge Meats |
| Top Pick | Dante's Delicatessen |
| Top Pick | Deep River's Pharmacy & UK Goodies |
| Top Pick | His & Hers Gourmet Grazing |
| Top Pick | Schmecken Bakery |