| Platinum | Joes Family Pizzeria & Poutinerie |
| Gold | Sour Jo's |
| Silver | Dino's Pizza |
| Bronze | Toppers |
| Top Pick | Finnigan's Roadhouse |
| Top Pick | Karras' Way |
| Top Pick | Neat Cafe |
| Top Pick | Nick's Chicken House |
| Top Pick | Petawawa Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Pizza Hut |
| Top Pick | Slice of Renfrew |
| Top Pick | Valley Buns Bakery and Deli |